The Knot You Can Never Untie: Trefoils and Topology
Grab a shoelace. Tie a simple overhand knot in it, then glue the two ends together to make a loop. No matter how much you twist, stretch, or wiggle that loop, without cutting it, you will never be able to smooth it back into a plain circle. Mathematicians call that plain circle the unknot, and the shape you just made the trefoil knot, and telling them apart without cutting anything is one of the oldest puzzles in topology.
What You'll Learn
- What topology studies, and how it is different from regular geometry - Why the unknot and the trefoil are provably different shapes, not just different-looking ones - How mathematicians count crossings to classify knots - Why this math shows up in DNA, not just shoelaces
Shapes That Can Stretch
In regular geometry, a square and a circle are permanently different because one has corners and straight sides. Topology asks a stranger question: if a shape were made of infinitely stretchy rubber, and you could bend, stretch, and squish it however you like, but never cut it or glue new parts together, which shapes could you turn into each other? Under those rules, a coffee mug and a donut are the same shape, because you can squish the mug's body down into the shape of the handle's loop without ever cutting the clay. A circle and a square are also the same shape, since a square is just a stretched circle. But a circle and a trefoil knot are never the same, no matter how you stretch either one, because the knot's loop is tangled through itself in a way stretching cannot undo.
The Unknot
The unknot is topology's name for a loop of string with no crossings at all, a plain circle. It sounds too simple to deserve a name, but it matters because every other knot is measured against it: a shape 'is knotted' precisely when it cannot be smoothed into the unknot without cutting the loop.
The Trefoil: The Simplest True Knot
The trefoil is the simplest knot that is genuinely, unremovably tangled. Lay it flat and count where the string crosses over or under itself: exactly three crossings, which is the fewest crossings any true knot can have. (One or two crossings can always be wiggled loose back into the unknot; three is the minimum for a knot that sticks.) Mathematicians proved the trefoil is truly different from the unknot using an invariant, a number or algebraic expression you calculate from a knot's crossings that stays exactly the same no matter how you stretch or wiggle the knot. If two knots have different invariants, they are provably, permanently different shapes. The unknot's simplest invariant is trivial (essentially 1); the trefoil's is not, which is the proof that no amount of stretching turns one into the other.
Trefoil-shaped knots show up in the strands of your own DNA. When DNA gets tangled during copying, cells use enzymes called topoisomerases to cut the strand, pass another part through the gap, and reseal it, precisely the 'cutting' move topology says is required to undo a real knot.
Left-Handed and Right-Handed Trefoils
Here is a twist even a trefoil hides: it comes in two mirror-image versions, one that twists clockwise and one that twists counterclockwise, and you cannot stretch one into the other in three-dimensional space, only by flipping through a mirror. Chemists care about this exact same idea, called chirality, when a molecule and its mirror image are different substances with different effects in the body.
Cut a piece of string about two feet long. Tie a simple overhand knot, then join the ends with tape to make a loop. Try for two full minutes to smooth it into a plain circle without untaping it. You will feel exactly why topologists needed real math, not just fiddling, to prove it is impossible.
Why can a topologist say a donut and a coffee mug are 'the same shape'?
What is the minimum number of crossings needed to make a knot that cannot be undone into the unknot?
Build a Knot Table
Using a two-foot piece of string or shoelace, create four loops by taping the ends together: one with zero crossings, one with a trefoil (three crossings), and try making two more different-looking knots with more crossings. For each, draw the loop on paper, count and label the crossings, and note whether you think it could be smoothed flat into a circle without cutting. Turn in your labeled drawings as your knot table.
Want to keep learning?
Sign up for free to access the full curriculum — all subjects, all ages.
Start Learning Free